Back to all articles
Checklist, document and keys illustrating the evidence a check-out report needs for a fair deposit dispute

What evidence should a check-out report include to help settle deposit disputes fairly?

19 November 20263 min read
Checklist, document and keys illustrating the evidence a check-out report needs for a fair deposit dispute

A fair check-out report should record inspection details, compare each disputed item with its check-in baseline, describe changes precisely, link dated photographs, note limitations and preserve tenant comments. The supporting dispute bundle should explain responsibility and justify costs with repair records, itemised estimates or invoices, and allowances for age and condition. The report records evidence; it does not determine liability.

Key takeaways

  • A fair check-out report records observations rather than a verdict.
  • Its evidence chain should establish the starting condition, what changed, responsibility and reasonable loss.
  • Use comparable item-by-item entries, dated and labelled photographs, clear inspection limitations and preserved tenant explanations.
  • Supporting correspondence and cost evidence belong in an indexed dispute bundle.

Need an inventory, check-in or check-out report in Slough or the surrounding area? Book online at agepc.co.uk/book or call 020 3051 3973.

Frequently asked questions

Who must prove entitlement to a deposit deduction?

DPS explains that the landlord must establish entitlement to a deduction. The deposit remains the tenant’s money until the claim is proven. Evidence should establish the starting condition, the change, responsibility and the reasonable loss.

When should a check-out inspection take place?

TDS recommends inspecting promptly after the tenant has fully vacated and before cleaning or remedial work. This preserves the condition being assessed; it is not a universal legal deadline. Record vacancy, key return and any intervening access or work.

Does an unsigned check-out report automatically fail as evidence?

No. DPS explains that an unsigned check-out report is not automatically rejected. Signatures, emails or texts can support evidence of agreement. Preserve evidence that the report was shared and the tenant could respond, but do not treat silence as acceptance.

Can a landlord make a claim without an inventory?

An absent inventory makes comparison harder, but does not automatically defeat every claim. TDS allows consideration of alternative evidence. The claim should identify what that evidence establishes rather than assume an unsupported starting condition.

Are photographs enough to prove tenant responsibility?

Not by themselves. Photographs can show a change but may not establish its cause. Repair notifications, maintenance responses, permissions and tenant explanations may be needed. Photographs also cannot establish odours and may represent dust or scale poorly.

Can a deduction cover the full cost of a new replacement?

A claim should not automatically charge the tenant the full price of a new item. TDS says compensation should avoid new-for-old improvement, or betterment. The calculation should account for age, existing condition and remaining useful life; there is no universal depreciation rate.

Should cleanliness be recorded separately from condition?

Yes. A scratched hob can be clean and an undamaged hob can be greasy. TDS warns that a check-in record describing condition alone cannot show whether cleanliness got worse, so record both at check-in and check-out.

How should photographs be taken for a check-out report?

TDS recommends clear, dated photographs linked to the relevant report entries. Mydeposits advises pairing a wider view that shows where the issue is with a close-up, using a ruler where size matters, and captioning each image with the room and item.

Sources

  1. Your TDS guide to: Inventories, check-in & check-out reports Tenancy Deposit Scheme (TDS)
  2. Common dispute questions Deposit Protection Service (DPS)
  3. Evidence for deposit disputes: what you need and how to prepare it mydeposits
  4. How TDS approaches disputes involving damage and missing items Tenancy Deposit Scheme (TDS)
  5. Evidence for a deposit dispute Shelter England
  6. What is alternative dispute resolution and how does it work in a tenancy deposit dispute? SafeDeposits Scotland

Frequently Asked Questions

DPS explains that the landlord must establish entitlement to a deduction. The deposit remains the tenant’s money until the claim is proven. Evidence should establish the starting condition, the change, responsibility and the reasonable loss.

Related articles